Calstuff
Don't mess this up!
-Kevin Deenihan,
Emeritus


Home
Archive
Extended

Help CalStuff!

Disclaimer: Calstuff and/or the opinions expressed are not affiliated with the University of California, Berkeley.
Recent Guest Posts
Tenants' Rights Week
by Jason Overman
Search

Powered by:
Contact
Email Calstuff
FaceBook CalStuff!
Allen L.
 About
 E-mail
 IM
Andy R.
 About
 E-mail
 IM
Ben N.
 About
 E-mail
 IM
Cooper N.

 About
 E-mail
 IM
Syndication
Site Feed (ATOM)
Comments Feed
Add to LJ Friends

Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Subscribe with Bloglines
Berkeley Blogs
CalJunket
With humor.
Cal Patriot Blog
Conservative Blog
UC Berkeley Livejournal
Discussion Forum
California Patriot Watch
Self Explanatory
Brad DeLong
Econ Prof
The Bird House
Cal Prof on everything
Cal Politik
Rants & Raves
Beetle Beat
Full Time Whiner
"Frat" Life
Cal "Frat" Boy
Cal Tzedek
Jewish Students Blog
Personal as Public
Soft Boiled Life
Hilariously Un-PC.
Cal Alumni/ Squelch Blogs
Kedstuff
Remember him?
I Fought the Law
Optimus Primed
Zembla
With Cuteness
Ne Quid Nimis
With Photography
Friday, March 01, 2002
# posted by Kevin @ 5:03 PM

Reader Matthew Picioccio writes
I think your analysis of Berdahl's statement misses a crucial point. You
have made the issue that the stealings are likely ideologically motivated.
The op-ed (reprinted under Berdahl's on your website) mentions this as well.
Berdahl is calling them perpetrators and speaking of jail time because he is
trying to avoid making this an ideological issue. This is quite the
opposite of what you suspect - "1. It makes reference to past attacks,
drawing clear parallels. Before, every paper-stealing or book burning was
taken on its own terms, with the ideologies involved being ignored and no
blame being placed. But this ties all the attacks together as one giant
community-dimishing whole." The ideologies are once again being willfully
ignored - if I may indulge in an extreme metaphor, it's like saying that Bin
Laden is a hoodlum who is in no way connected to radical Islam and it's
ideals. Pay no attention to the ideology behind the curtain.

"The personal is political" - this statement has now drawn us to one of it's
inevitable conclusions; namely, that your (free) speech doesn't please me,
therefore I should seek redress and deserve to do so and, what's more, it's
"right." Believe me, that's their mentality. I saw it all the time at
University of Maryland - we had similar shouting-down-of-speaker incidents
(we were one of the schools profiled in Stossel's excellent piece about this
behavior of a couple years back).

It's good that Berdahl is willing to speak strongly about the people who
actually did this. It's unfortunate and sadly predictable that he would
ignore the groups and the ideologies that drive those actions

Keep fighting the good fight.

Good points! Berdahl announced he'd be actively policing the boundaries of the debate, not the participants. I should've realized that.

Just to continue the Blogger tradition of getting in the last word, I doubt Berdahl could ever be driven so far as to single out groups or ideologies, and I'm not sure I want him to. Believe it or not, there are certain limits to the controversy I want on this silly campus, and the Chancellor attacking MECHA would cause every sorta-lefty group on campus to rise up in indignation.

Nor do I believe this would be good for the campus. I don't want an actively crusading Administration. Their preponderance of power leads to bad things. What I want is one that acts as impartial referree, safeguarding my rights of freedom of speech, freedom from harassment, etc. So I think Berdahl struck the right tone here.
Email This Post!

Home
Advertisements
Advertising Policy

Place an Ad on Calstuff



Get Firefox!

Cal Magazines
Heuristic Squelch
Humor Mag
California Patriot
Conservative
Hardboiled
Lefty/Asian mag.
Bezerk
Comics Mag
In Passing
Bloggish
Cal Newsites
Daily Californian
Student Newspaper
Daily Planet
City Newspaper
Berkeleyan
Faculty/Staff news
Newscenter
Administrative Announcements
Indybay
Hard Left News
East Bay Express
Alt-weekly
Cal Other
UC Rally Committee
Stand nineteen feet tall! Be united! Be tough! Be proud!
CyberBears
GO BEARS!
ASUC
Cal's Student government
One
Cal's Student Portal
Berkeley Bookswap
Good Deals

Weblog Commenting and Trackback by HaloScan.com